20 Best American Restaurants In Columbus, OH

Last Updated:
Sort
Northstar Café is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 951 North High Street. This restaurant serves made to order guacamole, bbq chicken flatbread, tim’s meatloaf sandwich, daily sandwich, classic tomato and cheese, northstar burger, and simple salad. They also serve both dips, sweet basil burrito, bbq pork burrito, high street veggie, soup of the day, pimiento cheese dip, and smoked...
951 North High Street, Columbus, OH, 43201
Rank
1
29 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Skillet is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 410 East Whittier Street. This restaurant serves tomatoes, biscuits, potatoes, local arugula, uncured ham, and farm to table. They are open every day except Monday and Tuesday. Although we do not accept reservations, we do accept call ahead seating on saturday and sunday; you can call to put your name on the wait list. We do ask that you call...
410 East Whittier Street, Columbus, OH, 43206
Rank
2
51 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Pat and Gracie's is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 138 Graceland Boulevard. Pat moved his club to a location in downtown Columbus and became rich. Pat parlayed his good fortune into another successful gambling venture - horseracing. While Pat tried to keep his gambling operations...
138 Graceland Boulevard, Columbus, OH, 43214
Rank
3
33 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Gallo's Kitchen & Bar is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 2820 Nottingham Road. They are open every day except Sunday. Gallo’s Kitchen sits in a small section of Arlington. As locals, we share with you our Italian heritage and love for Creole cuisine. Welcome to our family. Once a year...
2820 Nottingham Road, Columbus, OH, 43221
Rank
4
16 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Harvest Bar + Kitchen is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 2885 North High Street. They are open every day except Sunday. Below are just some of the Ohio partners we work with, from Produce and Dairy Farms, to Ohio-Proud meats:. Organic Shitake, Cremini, and Button Mushrooms, Micro...
2885 North High Street, Columbus, OH, 43202
Rank
5
16 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Thurman Cafe is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 183 Thurman Avenue. This restaurant serves pepperoni or mushroom pizza sub, our hot & spicy salsa burger, the thurman burger, grilled cheese, turkey reuben, our super italian sub, and the johnny burger. They also serve the blazin' burger, white pizza thin, pineapples, the hawaiian burger, bleu cheese burger, thurman cordon blue...
183 Thurman Avenue, Columbus, OH, 43206
Rank
6
85 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Tip Top Kitchen & Cocktails is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 73 East Gay Street. This restaurant serves smoked salmon fritters, tip top pot roast sandwich, spicy vegetarian corn chowder, tuna salad, bbq beef, meatloaf dinner, and beef and cheddar cheese ball. They also serve tonyas herbed goat cheese salad, turkey and goat cheese, mac n cheese, soup of the day, ohio nachos, cheese...
73 East Gay Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
Rank
7
62 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Wolf's Ridge Brewing is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 215 North 4th Street. They are open every day except Monday. Strawberry sorbet, rhubarb ice cream, lemon Chantilly, grenadine poached rhubarb, Elderflower macerated strawberry, strawberry jam, strawberry pearls, mint, shortcake (gfr) (v). Mole pork shoulder, braised black beans, dirty rice, cucumber & red onion salad, smoked sour...
215 North 4th Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
Rank
8
39 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Lindey's is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 169 East Beck Street. This restaurant serves eggs benedict, caesar, mussels, blackened chicken, haricot verts, baby kale & arugula, and house. They also serve orecchiette, flatbread, cobb, soup of the day, tuna nicoise, red snapper, and biscuits. They are open every day of the week. Host lunches, meetings, baby showers, engagement parties,...
169 East Beck Street, Columbus, OH, 43206
Rank
9
42 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Flip Side is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 3945 Easton Station. They are open every day of the week. Sprechers Root Beer $4 Make it a Float $6 Sprechers Orange $4 Sprechers Cream Soda $4 Fever Tree Ginger Beer $4 Red Bull / Sugar Free Red Bull $4 Coke / Diet Coke $2.99 Sprite / Gingerale / Coffee / Tea / Iced Tea $3 *These items are served raw or undercooked, or contain (may...
3945 Easton Station, Columbus, OH, 43219
Rank
10
39 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Tommy's Diner is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 914 West Broad Street. This restaurant serves philly steak / chicken philly, homemade meatloaf, roasted turkey, applesauce, pork chops, chicken breast, and breaded mushrooms. They also serve cottage cheese and peaches, gyro, soup of the day, french fries and gravy, double decker cheeseburger, greek, and chili cheese fries. They are open...
914 West Broad Street, Columbus, OH, 43222
Rank
11
11 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Super Chefs is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 199 East Broad Street. They are open every day except Monday. Childhood friends Ryan Bryson and Darnell Ferguson opened the first SuperChef’s Breakfast during the summer of 2012 in Louisville, KY. Meeting each other in the sixth grade, Darnell always had a knack for the kitchen, while Ryan was selling penny candy for 10 cents sharpening...
199 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
Rank
12
22 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Refectory Restaurant & Bistro is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 1092 Bethel Road. This restaurant serves pan seared loup de mer, duet of roasted salmon & chicken fricassee, pistachio & grand marnier crepe terrine, arctic char two ways, passed appetizers, european & domestic cheese symphony, and caesar salad. They also serve warm pear tarte, buffalo & confit of guinea hen terrine,...
1092 Bethel Road, Columbus, OH, 43220
Rank
13
5 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Milestone 229 is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 229 South Civic Center Drive. They are open every day of the week. Located in downtown Columbus, Milestone 229 is a premier dining restaurant. Connects Ohio State with downtown through a greenway corridor, providing recreational opportunities such as canoeing and kayaking Read More on Scioto Greenways». Sign up to receive announcements...
229 South Civic Center Drive, Columbus, OH, 43215
Rank
14
36 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Dirty Frank's Hot Dog Palace is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 248 South 4th Street. This restaurant serves jenis ice cream, hot bollywood, the texas tommy, split pea soup, tofurkey veggie dog, chili dog, and boston baked beans. They also serve beano, chicago, romaine lettuce wrap, gluten-free wrap, sauerkraut dog, the glenn beck, and tater tot-chos-alex style. They are open every...
248 South 4th Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
Rank
15
90 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Katalina's is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 1105 Pennsylvania Avenue. This restaurant serves pulled pork tacos, southern brown betty biscuit balls, award-winning breakfast tacos, vegetarian biscuit balls, shagbark black bean tacos, pueblo blt, and shagbark huevos rancheros. They also serve mazatlan slow-roasted pork & egg, classico grilled cheese & salmorejo gazpacho, housemade...
1105 Pennsylvania Avenue, Columbus, OH, 43201
Rank
16
63 votes
Sponsor
0.0
J. Gilbert's Wood-Fired Steaks & Seafood is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 1 East Campus View Boulevard. This restaurant serves kim crawford 2014 (new zealand), sweet tooth, fried calamari, seaglass 2013 (santa barbara), calamari, bud light, and lagavulin 16 year. They also serve tea forte hot tea, macallan 18 year, shrimp durango, espresso, franciscan 2012 (napa valley), ahi tuna...
1 East Campus View Boulevard, Columbus, OH, 43235
Rank
17
19 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Barley's Brewing Company is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 467 North High Street. This restaurant serves grilled cheese, ham & turkey club, steak frites, house salad, pile high nachos, crispy fries, and holy 'shroom. They also serve grilled chicken club, fish and chips, spicy chicken pasta, soup of the day, beans and rice, chicken tenders platter, and blackened chicken. They are open...
467 North High Street, Columbus, OH, 43215
Rank
18
14 votes
Sponsor
0.0
South Village Grille is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 197 Thurman Avenue. They are open every day of the week. Raised in Columbus, Ohio, Anna began her career in hospitality in New York City in 2004. Under the tutelage of Charles Masson at the historic La Grenouille, and Daniel Bouloud at this flagship, Restaurant Daniel, Anna fell in love with the finer points of service, food, and...
197 Thurman Avenue, Columbus, OH, 43206
Rank
19
11 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Sycamore is a restaurant located in Columbus, Ohio at 262 East Sycamore Street. They are open every day except Sunday. Located in Columbus, Ohio, The Sycamore is a German Village gastropub focused on seasonal, local and organic fare, craft beers and excellent wines. Based around a casual neighborhood tavern with an exceptionally high level of food. Sounds simple because it is simple....
262 East Sycamore Street, Columbus, OH, 43206
Rank
20
15 votes
Sponsor
0.0