20 Best American Restaurants In Staten Island, NY

Last Updated:
Sort
Gatsby's On The Bay is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 695 Bay Street. They are open every day except Monday. Saxophone NIght every Friday 8pm - 11pm Jazz Trio every saturday 8pm - 11pm.
695 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY, 10304
Rank
1
20 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Daddys Os BBQ is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 35 Androvette Street. They are open every day of the week. As a member of our VIP Club, you will be the first to hear about the cool events and parties at Daddy O’s. Plus, you can earn exclusive savings and discounts and you just might be invited to some upcoming VIP Parties so check your phone! Get more information or 'STOP'...
35 Androvette Street, Staten Island, NY, 10309
Rank
2
32 votes
Sponsor
0.0
West Shore Inn Steakhouse is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 3955 Victory Boulevard. They are open every day of the week. Offering the BEST party menu in Staten Island. Our private party room is perfect for birthdays, communions, showers & more. Our party menu starts at just...
3955 Victory Boulevard, Staten Island, NY, 10314
Rank
3
10 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Lunchbox is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 1612 Forest Avenue. They are open every day of the week. I was in town on business working at the Staten Island costco . I always ask around for what’s the towns spot to eat at . Many of my customers recommended this spot as a great...
1612 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10302
Rank
4
13 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Call It A Wrap is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 1198 Forest Avenue. This restaurant serves fresh carrot juice, the diva, banana punch, fresh tuna salad, rice and vegetables, caesar salad pita, and whole wheat pasta. They also serve coffee, tuna and avocado, chicken burger...
1198 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10310
Rank
5
7 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Joe Broadway's Billiards & Sports Pub is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 2178 Forest Avenue. They are open every day of the week. Deep fried panko crusted braised pork shoulder + Joe Broadway's BBQ sauce. Hey! Wanna begin receiving exclusive JB's discounts and promotions? Drop us your email! Fried panko crusted braised pork shoulder served with homemade BBQ sauce.Grilled...
2178 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10303
Rank
6
7 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Lacey's Bridge Tavern is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 75 Innis Street. This restaurant serves original or spicy shoe string onion rings, chicken piccata, sauteed broccoli, real homemade mashed potatoes, fried calamari, chicken sidestreet, and chicken fingers. They also serve linguini clam sauce, katie's loaf of garlic bread, house salad, 114 lb. classic style chicken...
75 Innis Street, Staten Island, NY, 10302
Rank
7
7 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Alor Cafe is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 2110 Richmond Road. This restaurant serves country herb chicken, norwegian eggs benedict, chicken pops, chicken spaghetti bistro style, crispy prawn buns, vegetarian, and poulet au curry crepe. They also serve mediterranean dips, peanut butter marshmallow crepe, cobb salad, pasta da vinci, new york steak, breakfast chicken...
2110 Richmond Road, Staten Island, NY, 10306
Rank
8
19 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Bay Street Luncheonette is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 1189 Bay Street. They are open every day of the week.
1189 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY, 10305
Rank
9
6 votes
Sponsor
0.0
PepperJack Grill is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 316 Manor Road. They are open every day of the week. Re-branding a 70-year-old bar into a modern comfort food haven has been a culinary quest for one manor road entrepreneur By Jennifer Vikse • Photos By Luca Sforza • Read the full article here Melissa O’Connell is a fourth generation restaurateur on Staten Island, and her...
316 Manor Road, Staten Island, NY, 10314
Rank
10
11 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Basilio Inn is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 6 Galesville Court. This restaurant serves petto di pollo alla “basilio”, rigatoni alla carbonara, petto di pollo ai funghi, pesce del giorno, insalata mista “misticanza”, bucatini all’amatriciana, and risotto del giorno. They also serve vongole gratinate, piccata al limone, zuppa di pesce, mozzarella in “carrozza”, cozze al vino...
6 Galesville Court, Staten Island, NY, 10305
Rank
11
4 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Portobello Cafe is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 4221 Hylan Boulevard. This restaurant serves traditional basil pesto, 18th avenue feast, sauteed p.e.i. mussels, chocolate brownie sundae, tuscan grilled chicken, classic esacargot, and classic arugula salad. They also serve fried calamari, roasted stuffed portobello mushroom, penne vodka, asian crusted fried calamari, veal...
4221 Hylan Boulevard, Staten Island, NY, 10308
Rank
12
15 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Afternoones Restaurant is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 415 Forest Avenue. This restaurant serves old bay seafood capellini, original buffalo, drunken clams, caesar, nachos supreme, blue cheese au poivre, and signature penne. They also serve chickenwich, pork chops with guinness braised sauerkraut, french onion, garden, baked spinach, chicken parmigiana, and west brighton...
415 Forest Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10301
Rank
13
5 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Phunky Elephant Gastropub is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 1271 Bay Street. They are open every day except Monday.
1271 Bay Street, Staten Island, NY, 10305
Rank
14
22 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Page Plaza Diner is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 75 Page Avenue. This restaurant serves buffalo mozzerella, sauteed rack of lamb, tuscan fries, red snapper livornese villa d'este style, fettuccine bolognese, orecchiette, and penne. They also serve sauteed spinach, pork chop, tre colori salad, sauteed braccoli rabe, fried calamari, veal panarea-style, and gnocchi. They are...
75 Page Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
Rank
15
9 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Gavel Grill is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 9 Hyatt Street. This restaurant serves egg sandwich, cheese steak, chili cheese fries, large fresh fruit cup/ seasonal, the ribby, english muffin, and rice pudding. They also serve bowl of soup, bagels w/ cream cheese, b.l.t., bacon/ham/sausage, greek combo, grilled chicken cordon blue, and chicago dog. They are open every...
9 Hyatt Street, Staten Island, NY, 10301
Rank
16
8 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Hop Shoppe is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 372 Van Duzer Street. They are open every day of the week. Please fill out the form to make a reservation at The Hop Shoppe. We will reply shortly to confirm your reservation. Thank you!The Hop Shoppe is a Stapleton gastropub where Staten Islanders get their taste of beers, custom and classic cocktails and a flavor packed menu...
372 Van Duzer Street, Staten Island, NY, 10304
Rank
17
4 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Miller's Ale House is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 2883 Richmond Avenue. This restaurant serves hickory chicken sandwich, english style fish & chips, baked potato, catch of the day, fried clam platter, zinger®, and mashed potatoes. They also serve caesar, veggie wrap, capt. jack's buried treasure^, 12 oz. choice ribeye, blackened chicken sandwich, chicken caesar wrap, and...
2883 Richmond Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
Rank
18
27 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Max's Es-Ca is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 1559 Richmond Road. This restaurant serves seafood paella, chocolate dream, chicken satay, cajun chicken panini, grilled skirt steak, stuffed jumbo shrimp, and cold antipasto. They also serve sausage & peppers, beet and mixed field greens, tri-­colored, traditional caesar salad, seafood salad, oysters, and spicy tuna tartare....
1559 Richmond Road, Staten Island, NY, 10304
Rank
19
10 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Twisted Dish Tavern is a restaurant located in Staten Island, New York at 885 Annadale Road. They are open every day of the week. A new upscale tavern focusing on serving unique takes on comfort food in a friendly upbeat atmosphere.
885 Annadale Road, Staten Island, NY, 10312
Rank
20
12 votes
Sponsor
0.0