Best Italian Restaurants In Shelter Island, NY

Last Updated:
Sort
Vine Street Cafe is a restaurant located in Shelter Island, New York at 41 South Ferry Road. This restaurant serves ragu alla bolognese, lemon spinach, buttery corn succotash, local littleneck clams, all beef hotdog chili, chef's daily cheese selection, and artisanal cheese plate. They also serve moules, creamy au poivre sauce, house made truffle butter, frites w/ aioli, grilled skirt steak,...
41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Rank
1
10 votes
Sponsor
0.0
18 Bay is a restaurant located in Shelter Island, New York at 23 North Ferry Road. They are open every day except Tuesday. Moët &Chandon, Brut Rosé, “Grand Vintage”, Champagne, France, 2002 Pierre Gimonnet & Fils, Brut, "Blanc de Blancs", Champagne, France, NV Louis Roederer, Brut, "Premier", Champagne, France, NV Dom Pérignon, Brut, Champagne, France, 2003 Veuve Clicquot, Brut, Reims, France,...
23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Rank
2
3 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Bella Vita is a restaurant located in Shelter Island, New York at 3 North Ferry Road.
3 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Rank
3
1 votes
Sponsor
0.0

More Italian Restaurants Restaurants Near Shelter Island, NY

Edgewater Restaurant is a restaurant located in Hampton Bays, New York at 295 East Montauk Highway. This restaurant serves orecchiette broccoli rabe & sausage, gnocchetti bolognese, veal saltimboca, frutti di mare, broccoli rabe, risotto, and cheese pizza. They also serve shrimp oreganata & risotto, grilled filet mignon au poivre, sliced pear & gorgonzola pizza, burrata & bresaola, pasta al...
295 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946
Sponsor
0.0
Café Crust is a restaurant located in Southampton, New York at 850 County Road 39. Cafe Crust sources all organic greens & our dressings are prepared in house. Our chicken is free-range. Crust’s House Side Salad : Organic spring greens, grape tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, carrots & house vinaigrette $6 Caesar Salad : Organic romaine, homemade croutons, shaved parmesan cheese & caesar dressing...
850 County Road 39, Southampton, NY, 11968
Sponsor
0.0
Nick & Toni's is a restaurant located in East Hampton, New York at 136 North Main Street. This restaurant serves fricco, cinnamon ice cream cake, romaine salad, endive salad, caesar salad, seared hudson valley foie gras, and toasted angel food cake. They also serve garden tuscan kale, molten chocolate cake, fernet branca amaro, artisanal cheese plate, sautéed spinach, braised lamb shank, and...
136 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Sponsor
0.0
The Frisky Oyster is a restaurant located in Greenport, New York at 27 Front Street. This restaurant serves oysters friskafella, broccoli rabe, roasted pumpkin crème brulée, seared sea scallops, rack of lamb, blistered shishitos, and the best key lime pie. They also serve crispy tuna spring rolls, cashew crusted atlantic halibut, warm virginia pecan pie, roasted baby beet salad, prosciutto...
27 Front Street, Greenport, NY, 11944
Sponsor
0.0
Lenny's is a restaurant located in Riverhead, New York at 1451 Main Road. They are open every day of the week. Lenny has applied his traditional Brooklyn Italian roots and lifetime of service experience to our dining room menu. The focus on generous servings, premium ingredients, family recipes and one-of-a-kind pizza has made us a favorite on the North Fork. Our dining room menu, combined with...
1451 Main Road, Riverhead, NY, 11901
Sponsor
0.0
Caci is a restaurant located in Southold, New York at 56125 Main Road. They are open every day except Tuesday. Located in the Hamlet Business District in Southold on the North Fork of Long Island, Caci North Fork opened September 2014 inside a graciously restored turn of the century farmstead. A seasonally inspired menu featuring authentic northern Italian cuisine by Umbrian-born Executive Chef...
56125 Main Road, Southold, NY, 11971
Sponsor
0.0
75 Main is a restaurant located in Southampton, New York at 75 Main Street. This restaurant serves sausage, homemade granola, salmon, bacon, chile glazed bacon wrapped meat loaf, italian onion soup stracciatelle, and watermelon salad. They also serve fresh fish sandwich, grilled filet mignon, quesadillas, crispy shishito peppers, spaghetti with little clams red or white, grilled breast of long...
75 Main Street, Southampton, NY, 11968
Sponsor
0.0