Best American Restaurants In Shelter Island, NY

Last Updated:
Sort
Vine Street Cafe is a restaurant located in Shelter Island, New York at 41 South Ferry Road. This restaurant serves ragu alla bolognese, lemon spinach, buttery corn succotash, local littleneck clams, all beef hotdog chili, chef's daily cheese selection, and artisanal cheese plate. They also serve moules, creamy au poivre sauce, house made truffle butter, frites w/ aioli, grilled skirt steak,...
41 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Rank
1
10 votes
Sponsor
0.0
18 Bay is a restaurant located in Shelter Island, New York at 23 North Ferry Road. They are open every day except Tuesday. Moët &Chandon, Brut Rosé, “Grand Vintage”, Champagne, France, 2002 Pierre Gimonnet & Fils, Brut, "Blanc de Blancs", Champagne, France, NV Louis Roederer, Brut, "Premier", Champagne, France, NV Dom Pérignon, Brut, Champagne, France, 2003 Veuve Clicquot, Brut, Reims, France,...
23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Rank
2
3 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Salt is a restaurant located in Shelter Island, New York at 63 South Menantic Road. They are open every day except Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday.
63 South Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Rank
3
5 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Islander is a restaurant located in Shelter Island, New York at 63 North Ferry Road. They are open every day of the week. The Islander is a family restaurant located in beautiful Shelter Island, NY. We specialize in homestyle comfort food in a casual fun environment.
63 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Rank
4
3 votes
Sponsor
0.0

More American Restaurants Restaurants Near Shelter Island, NY

The Frisky Oyster is a restaurant located in Greenport, New York at 27 Front Street. This restaurant serves oysters friskafella, broccoli rabe, roasted pumpkin crème brulée, seared sea scallops, rack of lamb, blistered shishitos, and the best key lime pie. They also serve crispy tuna spring rolls, cashew crusted atlantic halibut, warm virginia pecan pie, roasted baby beet salad, prosciutto...
27 Front Street, Greenport, NY, 11944
Sponsor
0.0
Noah's is a restaurant located in Greenport, New York at 136 Front Street. This restaurant serves chick pea hummus, house marinated olives, beau solei oysters, roasted garlic clove, grilled mediterranean sardines, crab cake, and latham's white cauliflower gratin. They also serve filet mignon sliders, charred octopus, rock shrimp pasta, pan roasted local catch, local calamari fritto misto,...
136 Front Street, Greenport, NY, 11944
Sponsor
0.0
Cuvee Seafood & Grille is a restaurant located in Greenport, New York at 326 Front Street. They are open every day except Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday. The Greenporter Hotel is a 3-star, privately owned boutique hotel located in the heart of the North Fork’s wine country, in Greenport, Long Island. We located at the entrance of The Village of Greenport and are a short walk from village docks,...
326 Front Street, Greenport, NY, 11944
Sponsor
0.0
Estia's Little Kitchen is a restaurant located in Sag Harbor, New York at 1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike. This restaurant serves espresso, lemon cheesecake, chili chicken burrito, split pea, turtle rolls, apple & walnuts, and tortilla. They also serve mexican sweet corn, bbq glazed salmon, manchester farm grass fed burger, crab cakes, vegetable enchiladas barbaria, crab tostadas, and...
1615 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963
Sponsor
0.0
Vino n Vittles is a restaurant located in Greenport, New York at 110 Front Street. They are open every day of the week. Captains Platter (Fried only) two scallops, two shrimp, two oysters, flounder, crab cake, rice and vegetable 34. Halibut Sautéed drizzled with a creamy lemon butter caper sauce, served over a bed of rice with vegetable 26. Tuna Tartare Fresh Ahi Tuna, Avocados, seaweed, sesame...
110 Front Street, Greenport, NY, 11944
Sponsor
0.0
Founders Tavern is a restaurant located in Southold, New York at 55500 New York State Route 25. This restaurant serves fried calamari, fried shrimp, jr. burger, firecracker chips, jr. cheeseburger, cole slaw, and crock of french onion soup. They also serve mozzarella sticks, chicken wings or boneless bits, founders bar pie ultra-thin crust pizza, onion rings, loaded potato skins, baby back...
55500 New York State Route 25, Southold, NY, 11971
Sponsor
0.0