Best Italian Restaurants In Shelter Island Heights, NY

Last Updated:
Sort
Sweet Tomato's is a restaurant located in Shelter Island Heights, New York at 15 Grand Avenue. This restaurant serves scampi, ricotta dip, verdore del isola, artichokes dip, il filetto di manzo, scampi giganti, and tartufo. They also serve minestra del giorno, pesce del giorno, la pasta de baby sarah, involtini di radicchio, stracotto di manzo, tuscani, and salsiccia. They are open every day of...
15 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island Heights, NY, 11965
Rank
1
9 votes
Sponsor
0.0

More Italian Restaurants Restaurants Near Shelter Island Heights, NY

Edgewater Restaurant is a restaurant located in Hampton Bays, New York at 295 East Montauk Highway. This restaurant serves orecchiette broccoli rabe & sausage, gnocchetti bolognese, veal saltimboca, frutti di mare, broccoli rabe, risotto, and cheese pizza. They also serve shrimp oreganata & risotto, grilled filet mignon au poivre, sliced pear & gorgonzola pizza, burrata & bresaola, pasta al...
295 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946
Sponsor
0.0
Nick & Toni's is a restaurant located in East Hampton, New York at 136 North Main Street. This restaurant serves fricco, cinnamon ice cream cake, romaine salad, endive salad, caesar salad, seared hudson valley foie gras, and toasted angel food cake. They also serve garden tuscan kale, molten chocolate cake, fernet branca amaro, artisanal cheese plate, sautéed spinach, braised lamb shank, and...
136 North Main Street, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Sponsor
0.0
The Frisky Oyster is a restaurant located in Greenport, New York at 27 Front Street. This restaurant serves oysters friskafella, broccoli rabe, roasted pumpkin crème brulée, seared sea scallops, rack of lamb, blistered shishitos, and the best key lime pie. They also serve crispy tuna spring rolls, cashew crusted atlantic halibut, warm virginia pecan pie, roasted baby beet salad, prosciutto...
27 Front Street, Greenport, NY, 11944
Sponsor
0.0
Caci is a restaurant located in Southold, New York at 56125 Main Road. We will call to confirm reservations 1 to 2 days in advance. If you do not confirm by 2pm on the day of your reservation you will be moved to the waitlist. Parties of 5 or more guests. If reservations are cancelled less than 24 hours in advance. Should your plans change, please let us know. We look forward to seeing you. We...
56125 Main Road, Southold, NY, 11971
Sponsor
0.0
Alforno is a restaurant located in Old Saybrook, Connecticut at 1654 Boston Post Road. This restaurant serves spaghetti with littleneck clams, margherita, barbecued chicken, gorgonzola walnut salad, famous pizza, tagliatelle bolognese, and wild mushroom. They also serve flounder livornese, cannelloni florentine, penne toscano, chocolate torte (gluten free), caesar salad, veal and ricotta...
1654 Boston Post Road, Old Saybrook, CT, 06475
Sponsor
0.0
Tuscan House is a restaurant located in Southampton, New York at 10 Windmill Lane. This restaurant serves calamari fritti, vongolette oreganata, polenta al forno, cavatelli alla tage, broccoli di rabe, fettucine alla katie, and caprese. They also serve crostini cavolo e carciofi, inverno, livornese, zuppa del giorno, asparagi griglia, quattro formaggio, and bucatini al amatriciana. Mixed...
10 Windmill Lane, Southampton, NY, 11968
Sponsor
0.0
Sam's is a restaurant located in East Hampton, New York at 36 Newtown Lane. This restaurant serves shrimp parmigiana, baked ziti, seafood, chicken cutlet parmigiana, homemade soup, greek salad, and rosaline salad. They also serve half herb roasted chicken, cheese, veal milanese, angel hair pasta, pasta, baked clams, and clam. They are open every day of the week. Sam's Restaurant East Hampton...
36 Newtown Lane, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Sponsor
0.0
Cittanuova is a restaurant located in East Hampton, New York at 29 Newtown Lane. This restaurant serves broccoletti, pane frattau, carciofi alla giudea, tagliatelle, insalata fagiolini, fagioli, and orecchiette. They also serve zuppa pomodoro, formaggi, minestrone, pollo, salumi, milanese, and garganelli. They are open every day of the week. Buonasera Bistecca, or Steak Night as it's commonly...
29 Newtown Lane, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Sponsor
0.0
Luigi's Italian Specialties is a restaurant located in East Hampton, New York at 199 Pantigo Place. This restaurant serves veal parmigiana, spinach and cheese ravioli, soups, penne, penne provincale, grilled chicken, and fettuccine. They also serve party size heroes, cold antipasto, broccoli rabe ravioli, baked ziti, penne with ham, fresh tomato & basil, and eggplant rollatini.
199 Pantigo Place, East Hampton, NY, 11937
Sponsor
0.0