19 Best American Restaurants In Montauk, NY

Last Updated:
Sort
Harvest on Fort Pond is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 11 South Emery Street. They are open every day of the week. At each Fort Pond Bay Company property, we are proud to present perfect meals, accompanied by waterfront vistas in highly distinctive yet completely comfortable environments. Harvest On Fort Pond, one of Montauk’s top Zagat rated restaurants, is nestled on Fort...
11 South Emery Street, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
1
33 votes
Sponsor
0.0
668 Gig Shack is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 782 Main Street. They are open every day of the week.
782 Main Street, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
2
20 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Ruschmeyer's is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 161 2nd House Road. This restaurant serves market vegetable frittata, seasonal fruit bowl, hanger steak, brunch flatbread, lobster roll, watermelon, and cheeseburger. They also serve black seed bagel and schmear, grilled swordfish...
161 2nd House Road, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
3
13 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Crow's Nest is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 4 Old West Lake Drive. This restaurant serves blackened mahi mahi, captain"s burger, summer pesto pasta, sizzling summer shrimp, surf and turf oscar, fire-grilled pizza, and nautical nachos. They also serve sesame tuna & asian slaw,...
4 Old West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
4
9 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Swallow East Restaurant is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 474 West Lake Drive. They are open every day except Monday. Swallow East Restaurant is one of the premier dining locations in Montauk NY. We feature a small plate menu consisting of local fresh ingiedients.
474 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
5
16 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Navy Beach is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 16 Navy Road. This restaurant serves navy burger, edamame, chilled shrimp, pappardelle alle verdure, dry-aged ny strip, crispy calamari, and beet & arugula. They also serve shaved cucumber, crispy rock shrimp, jumbo lump crab cake, charred shishito peppers, broiled asparagus, mtk seafood stew, and seared atlantic salmon. They are open...
16 Navy Road, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
6
22 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Saltbox Restaurant and Bar is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 99 Edgemere Street. They are open every day except Tuesday and Wednesday. The Saltbox is a chill eatery providing casual American dining in a relaxed and light-filled atmosphere. The Saltbox is located in the heart of Montauk, a stone’s throw from Route 27. The highly anticipated restaurant and bar is a collaboration...
99 Edgemere Street, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
7
7 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Bird On the Roof is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 47 South Elmwood Avenue. They are open every day of the week.
47 South Elmwood Avenue, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
8
10 votes
Sponsor
0.0
La Fine is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 236 Edgemere Street. They are open every day of the week. Lafine is located inside the Montauk Manor on Long Island, New York. Perfect event venue for egagement parties, wedding rehearsal dinners, corporate events and private affairs. Imagine your special day in our charming space with the friendly folks at La Fine. We know how to make...
236 Edgemere Street, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
9
5 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Fishbar is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 467 East Lake Drive. They are open every day of the week. Executive Chef Jennifer Meadows & Daniel Grimm opened Fishbar together in 2006. Jennifer was formally trained at Johnson & Wales University and has 12 years experience cooking in culinary hot spots such as San Diego, CA, Oahu, HI, Washington D.C and now on the beautiful shores of...
467 East Lake Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
10
9 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Red Hook Lobster MTK is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 34 South Etna Avenue. They are open every day of the week.
34 South Etna Avenue, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
11
7 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Surfside Inn is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 685 Old Montauk Highway. This restaurant serves creamy cheddar grits, pan seared sesame crusted tuna, surfside's summer shrimp & penne, soup of the day, littleneck clams on the 1/2 shell (raw), corn on the cob, and citrus glazed grilled salmon. They also serve herb gnocchi, pei mussels, savannah style shrimp, french fries, pulled bbq...
685 Old Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
12
4 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Shagwong Restaurant is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 774 Montauk Highway. They are open every day of the week.
774 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
13
18 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Point is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 697 Montauk Highway. They are open every day of the week. Crispy buffalo chicken strips wrapped in a tortilla with bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion and blue cheese dressing. Fresh local fish, pan-fried with lemon garlic and herbs. Served with lettuce, tomato, onion and tartar sauce. Grilled chicken breast, wrapped in a tortilla with bacon,...
697 Montauk Highway, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
14
1 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Tillie's is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 290 Old Montauk Hwy. This restaurant serves avocado tartine, styled omelette, challah french toast, lobster roll, oysters, grilled cheese, and grilled asparagus. They also serve beet salad, steak frites, clams, mac and cheese, apple wood bacon, daily whole fish a la plancha, and everything bagel with lox. They are open every day of the...
290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
15
1 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Munch Box is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 41 The Plaza.
41 The Plaza, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
16
1 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Lucky J's Chicken & Waffles is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 440 West Lake Drive. They are open every day except Tuesday and Saturday. At Lucky J’s we serve up Southern Classics with a Texas flare. Our original trailer opened up on Burnet Road in the Spring of 2009 serving the traditional dish of fried chicken and waffles. When it was time to launch our second location on E. 6th...
440 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
17
1 votes
Sponsor
0.0
O'Murphy's Pub is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 432 West Lake Drive. They are open every day of the week. Blackened Chicken over Caesar Salad, Sautéed Chicken Picatta,. 2 Eggs (any style) 1/2 grilled tomato & Homemade Brown Bread. Spicy Tuna, Penne ala Vodka, Chicken Parmesan over Linguine,. Imported Irish Sausage, Irish Bacon, Black & White Pudding. Chicken Marsala, Swordfish,...
432 West Lake Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
18
1 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Gulf Coast Kitchen is a restaurant located in Montauk, New York at 32 Star Island Road. This restaurant serves ribeye, butter croissant, award winning clam chowder, octopus salad, lobster risotto, steel cut oatmeal, and bbq chicken. They also serve filet mignon, choice of a selection of breakfast cereals, amagansett sea salt crusted jumbo scallops, scones, toast or english muffin, brioche...
32 Star Island Road, Montauk, NY, 11954
Rank
19
1 votes
Sponsor
0.0