20 Best Italian Restaurants In Brooklyn, NY

Last Updated:
Sort
Paulie Gee's is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 60 Greenpoint Avenue. They are open every day of the week. Vegan tomato sauce with tomatoes, olive oil, Vidalia onions, garlic, basil, salt, and pepper 10 Add house-made vegan fennel sausage, cashew ricotta, house-pickled red onions, or house-pickled red grape halves 3 each Add sliced red onion, baby arugula, sliced cremini...
60 Greenpoint Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11222
Rank
1
143 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Sottocasa Pizzeria is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 298 Atlantic Avenue. They are open every day of the week. Literally, in italian sotto means under, and casa home. And that’s where we are, few steps down from Atlantic Avenue’s vibrant sidewalk, nestled at the very bottom of a brick townhouse. But being “sottocasa”, is less about a physical location and more about a Feeling: it...
298 Atlantic Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11201
Rank
2
64 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Peppino's is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 469 5th Avenue. This restaurant serves meatball parmigiana, lasagna, ceasar grilled chicken, lentil soup, garlic crisps, fusilli fridiavola, and grilled chicken. They also serve seafood salad, garlic crisp, baked clams, mixed salad,...
469 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11215
Rank
3
48 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Saint Austere is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 613 Grand Street. This restaurant serves branzino, quail, brussel sprouts, grilled prawns, pecorino rossellino (sheep) (italy), creamy polenta, and gorgonzola dolce (cow) (france). They also serve broccoli rabe, grilled octopus,...
613 Grand Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11211
Rank
4
38 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Lioni Italian Heroes is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 7803 15th Avenue. This restaurant serves #25 the louie prima, #7a joe garagiola, #129 a great hero after 5 great singers, #20 robert deniro, stuffed mushrooms, #29 the pavarotti, and #2 dean martin (dino paul crocetti). They...
7803 15th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11228
Rank
5
36 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Lucali is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 575 Henry Street. This restaurant serves onions, basil, garlic, calzone, artichoke hearts, pie, and portabello mushrooms. They also serve peppers, pepperoni, and shallots. They are open every day except Tuesday.
575 Henry Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11231
Rank
6
131 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Forno Rosso is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 327 Gold Street. This restaurant serves gelati misti, pappardelle ai funghi, potato croquette, pollo arrosto, lasagna bolognese, bistecca di carne, and broccoli rabe. They also serve kale caesar salad, vegetable crudite, insalata di frutta con gelato alla vaniglia, calzone classico, meatball, pizza nutella-ferrero, and regina...
327 Gold Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11201
Rank
7
23 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Di Fara Pizza is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 1424 Avenue J. This restaurant serves pizza slices, cheese w/ one topping, square pie, difara classic pie, square pie (w/ specialty topping), cheese, and regular pie (w/ topping). They also serve square pie (w/ topping), regular pie,...
1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY, 11230
Rank
8
332 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Roberta's is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 261 Moore Street. This restaurant serves eastham scollops, smoked ribs, pizza toppings a, crispy glover, snap peas, wagyu flank steak, and roy rogers. They also serve calzone, biscuit, margherita, cowabunga dude, pork collar cemita, sea...
261 Moore Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11206
Rank
9
248 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Meatball Shop is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 170 Bedford Avenue. This restaurant serves brown sugar, unsweetened iced tea, house-made ice cream, ice cream, special, mint, and snickerdoodle. They also serve spicy pork, iced sweet tea, ginger, vanilla, chocolate chip,...
170 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11211
Rank
10
144 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Al Di La Trattoria is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 248 5th Avenue. This restaurant serves crushed yukon gold potatoes, zuppa del giorno malfatti, calf liver alla veneziana, crispy squashed beets, farro salad, hanger steak “tagliata” with arugula, and cavolo nero salad. They also serve braised rabbit, fish of the day, tagliatelle al ragu’, steamed bouchot mussels, galletto alla...
248 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11215
Rank
11
82 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Frankies 457 is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 457 Court Street. This restaurant serves house-made pappardelle, heirloom squash, prosciutto and pecorino, frankies greens, buffalo mozzarella and arugula, chicken liver, and dandelion greens. They also serve spicy soppressata, chocolate tart, sweet potato & sage ravioli, vanilla creme brulee, broccoli rabe, rosso de langhe, and...
457 Court Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11231
Rank
12
91 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Fornino is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 187 Bedford Avenue. This restaurant serves gorgonzola, pugliese, genovese, calabrese, caesar, lombardi, and eggplant caponata crostini. They also serve spinach, chickpeas & shaved parmesan, lemon & olive oil cake, beets & ricotta salata, carciofo e salsiccia, napoletana, and marinated olives. They are open every day of the week. See The...
187 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11211
Rank
13
92 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Mariella is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 492 6th Avenue. They are open every day of the week. Boneless braised short ribs in a red wine sage reduction with garlic potato puree and vegetables. North Atlantic salmon caper berry white wine reduction with sautéed kale and purple cabbage. Mix shaved cabbage, apple and chickpea salad in a lemon and garlic vinaigrette. Brown rice...
492 6th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11215
Rank
14
16 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Aurora is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 70 Grand Street. This restaurant serves tagliata di vitello, caffé corretto, garganelli al sugo calabrese, formaggi, misticanza, tartare di manzo, and pomodori e fagiolini. They also serve pannacotta e visciole, prosciutto e burrata, polipo alla griglia, pesce del giorno, crudo di tonno, pizzetta bufala e pachino, and pappardelle con osso...
70 Grand Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11249
Rank
15
62 votes
Sponsor
0.0
La Villa is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 261 5th Avenue. This restaurant serves arancini, rigatoni alla vodka, calzone, sottosopra, marinara col gamberi, speciale, and spaghetti primavera. They also serve pasta "la villa" con pappardelle, romano, siciliana, grilled fennel sausage or grilled herb chicken, minestrone di riso, pollo caesar salad, and marinara. They are open every...
261 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11215
Rank
16
54 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Gino's Restaurant is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 7414 5th Avenue. This restaurant serves linguine with clam sauce red or white, black & white chocolate mousse, tea, tiramisu, shrimp oreganata, fried calamari, and chocolate mousse. They also serve caesar salad, espresso, bowtie with broccoli in white broth, orecchiette with broccoli rabe and sausage, grilled portobello...
7414 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11209
Rank
17
48 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Convivium Osteria is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 68 5th Avenue. This restaurant serves gnudi di ricotta di pecora e spinaci all'asiago, mezzemaniche con salsiccia e broccoli, gamberetti all'aglio con paprica, carpaccio di manzo con carciofo e parmigiano, burrata con pomodoro e basilico, tagliatelle al ragú di carne, and cataplana de ameijoas com chouriço. They also serve...
68 5th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11217
Rank
18
55 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Scottadito Osteria Toscana is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 788 A Union Street. This restaurant serves pane dolce alla nutella e banana, rack of lamb, l'ortolana, insalata di kim, affettati misti for two, mesclun salad, and polpo alla griglia. They also serve fettuccine zafferano & frutti di mare, grass fed rib eye steak, insalata caterina, salmone scottadito, warm mediterranean...
788 A Union Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11215
Rank
19
96 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Vinnie's Pizzeria is a restaurant located in Brooklyn, New York at 148 Bedford Avenue. This restaurant serves vinnie's great grandma pizza, grilled chicken salad, mac attack pizza, cookie, sicilian pizza pie, alice in wonderland pizza (vegan), and eggplant parmigiana pizza (vegan). They also serve large half cheese & half topping pizza, mixed veggies pizza, fried chicken salad, small half...
148 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn, NY, 11211
Rank
20
73 votes
Sponsor
0.0