20 Best American Restaurants In Indianapolis, IN

Last Updated:
Sort
Bluebeard is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 653 Virginia Avenue. They are open every day of the week. Bluebeard is a restaurant and bar located in the historic Holy Rosary Neighborhood on the southeast edge of downtown Indianapolis. Abbi Merriss has joined up with longtime friends Tom and Eddie Battista to create a unique food-focused experience. The menu offers contemporary...
653 Virginia Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46203
Rank
1
53 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Tinker Street is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 402 East 16th Street. They are open every day of the week. Colorado Bison Strip Steak Sweet Corn Chili, Ground Cherry Salsa [29]. Tuna Watermelon, Smoked Tomato, Peppers, Okra, Preserved Ramps [23]. Chicken Tabbouleh, Cucumber, Yogurt, Dill, Mint, Lemon, Tomato [17]. Beet Cured Wild Salmon Fennel, Whipped Chive Honey, Caviar...
402 East 16th Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
Rank
2
26 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Legend Classic Irvington Cafe is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 5614 East Washington Street. This restaurant serves iced brownies, roasted vegetable lentil bowl, mixed baby greens, chef's choice salmon, cheese, b. b. b, and broccoli slaw. They also serve made-from-scratch...
5614 East Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46219
Rank
3
17 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Lincoln Square Pancake House is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 2330 North Meridian Street. They are open every day of the week. Lincoln Square Pancake House is a family owned and operated restaurant in central Indiana. Lincoln square was started by George Katris, but now his...
2330 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46208
Rank
4
19 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Eagle is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 310 Massachusetts Avenue. They are open every day of the week. We Cincinnati foodies tend to trip over one another whenever a new restaurant opens in Over-the-Rhine, clamoring to be among the first to experience it and talk about it...
310 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46204
Rank
5
14 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Ralph's Great Divide is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 743 East New York Street. This restaurant serves cottage cheese, chicken club, hot pot hog aka pig, chicken or tuna salad plate, applesauce, german potato salad, and blt. They also serve breads, cheese burger club, soup and salad, the half sandwich "trombo", soup of the moment, divide miss "p", and roasted prime rib of...
743 East New York Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
Rank
6
12 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Meridian Restaurant & Bar is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 5694 North Meridian Street. This restaurant serves bacon and eggs, caesar, pork belly macaroni and cheese, spicy garlic shrimp, heitz cellars "ink grade", macaroni & cheese, and smoked corn puree. They also serve chicken soup, mashed potatoes, biscuits and gravy, short rib tacos, verlasso salmon, chips with remoulade,...
5694 North Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46208
Rank
7
15 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Harry & Izzy's is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 153 South Illinois Street. This restaurant serves potato pancakes, vegetable soup, south african lobster tails, club sandwich, spinach, house-made onion rings, and fresh-cut fries. They also serve sorbet, mini bone-in filet chops, thin crust pizza, bone-in ribeye, signature brownie, gluten free fries, and oven roasted beet...
153 South Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46225
Rank
8
60 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Punch Burger is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 137 East Ohio Street. They are open every day of the week. Punched Up Cheese Platter (Includes Extra Burnt Cheese, Cheddar, American, Pepper Jack, and Blue Cheese Crumbles) $1/person. Salad, Dressings & Cookie PUNCH HOUSE SALAD - Grilled Chicken, Mixed Greens, Bacon, Red Onions, Blue Cheese Crumbles. The mission is simple: serve...
137 East Ohio Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46204
Rank
9
53 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Taste Cafe & Marketplace is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 5164 North College Avenue. This restaurant serves chicken liver bruschetta, sweet potato frites, slow roasted salmon, breaded chicken cutlet, smoked ham, french or wheat baguette slice, and asparagus prosciutto. They also serve pommes frites, blue cheese and bacon dip, roasted chorizo, marinated olive bowl, dates,...
5164 North College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46205
Rank
10
43 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Ball & Biscuit is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 331 Massachusetts Avenue. This restaurant serves cajun style pork or catfish tacos, goose the market butcher plate, muffaletta, kim chi dog, papa roux trio of po boys, house marinated olives, and artichoke dip. They also serve goose the market sausage plate, pick 3 cheese board, mixed green salad, chicken & sausage stew,...
331 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46204
Rank
11
34 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Shoefly Public House is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 122 East 22nd Street. This restaurant serves anna, lucy, tomato & basil nachos, romaine, shoofly pie, lilah, and chili maple smoked pork chop. They also serve breakfast pizza, griddled polenta, scrambled egg w/bacon & potatoes, farro, camila, avalena, and asparagus. They are open every day except Sunday. As to...
122 East 22nd Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
Rank
12
40 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Palomino is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 49 West Maryland Street. This restaurant serves salsiccia fresca, palomino french dip, fresh roma & mozzarella, truffle deviled eggs, the palomino chop chop, caprese panini, and bud light draft. They also serve rigatoni or capellini, bottomless mimosa, herradura silver, bulleit rye, prosciutto crudo, pizza, and corpse reviver. They...
49 West Maryland Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46204
Rank
13
35 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Black Market is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 922 Massachusetts Avenue. They are open every day except Monday and Sunday. Our wine director, Chris Coy, curates a wine list that focuses on terroir-driven wines that are balanced, well-crafted, and convey a sense of place rather than just an abundance of fruit. “We believe that everyone can have an amazing experience with a...
922 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
Rank
14
31 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurants is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 3815 East 96th Street. This restaurant serves blackened ahi tuna, dessert, salmanazar 9 liter, citrus-glazed salmon & kale, grilled prime sirloin, raspberry, and fruit. They also serve asparagus, viognier, chicken chorizo burger, sauvignon blanc, asian pork belly tostadas^, , and chicken tenders. They are...
3815 East 96th Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46240
Rank
15
24 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Mimi Blue Meatballs is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 874 Massachusetts Avenue. They are open every day of the week. 100% beef mixed with onion and chili powder, topped with a Bourbon BBQ Sauce. Special brunch menu served. Regular menu also available during Brunch.Mimi Blue Meatballs is a tribute to our mother “Mimi Blue” Kosene. Mimi was a Lady, endowed with manners, taste,...
874 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN, 46202
Rank
16
33 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Oceanaire Seafood Room is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 30 South Meridian Street. This restaurant serves ahi tuna poke, whole maryland black bass, caesar salad "royale", double-cut pork chop, three crab cakes sliders, north bay, and stingray. They also serve samish river, creamed corn, steamed p. e. i. mussels, patty melt, blackened fish tacos, classic clams casino, and...
30 South Meridian Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46204
Rank
17
28 votes
Sponsor
0.0
The Capital Grille is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 40 W Washington Street. This restaurant serves parmesan truffle fries, lobster and crab cakes, pan-seared sea scallops, chicken fingers, spring artichoke bisque, sliced filet mignon, and french onion soup. They also serve scrambled eggs with cheese, grilled asparagus, french toast, lollipop lamb chops (4), roasted wild...
40 W Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46204
Rank
18
29 votes
Sponsor
0.0
Seasons 52 is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 8650 Keystone Crossing. This restaurant serves vegetable frittata, signature burger, shrimp scampi skillet, spring vegetarian tasting, ahi tuna tartare, jam jar sweet white blend, and lump crab cake. They also serve wood-grilled new york strip, artichoke & laura chenel goat cheese, corona extra, lump crab cake sandwich, grilled...
8650 Keystone Crossing, Indianapolis, IN, 46240
Rank
19
33 votes
Sponsor
0.0
SoBro Cafe is a restaurant located in Indianapolis, Indiana at 653 East 52nd Street. They are open every day of the week. Whether you're in the mood for a simple chicken salad sandwich or our blackened organic tofu, SoBro is a great place to come for dinner in Indianapolis. Whether you’re in the mood for a simple chicken salad sandwich or our special blackened organic tofu, SoBro is a great...
653 East 52nd Street, Indianapolis, IN, 46205
Rank
20
23 votes
Sponsor
0.0